Cannot find apps on SDcard after flashing Custom ROM

I just took the plunge and flashed my HTC Incredible 2 with _stock ICS 4.0.4_ to _Psycho's CM 9.1_. I am happy so far but I don't know how to retrieve the apps I have saved on my SD card. Prior to performing a root, I used App2SD pro to move them. Now after rooting and flashing custom ROM they don't show up on SD card. I re-installed App2SD pro and still can't find them. I know they are there because file manager says there is 14GB of used space. I could re-download everything but I would like to avoid that. Any help for a noob would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.