Wrong caller ID for home number

I recently had to wipe my Nexus 4 in order to root it. Prior to that when I received a call from my home telephone it would display my wife's contact from the caller ID. Since rooting it now displays my own contact instead. My contacts are synced from my Google account and I haven't changed anything on my Google account. The only thing that has changed is the wipe and root. How can I get it to display my wife's contact again?